D. P. Cole's review and rating:
This is more proof that season 3 is far from being an entirely wasted season. Of course, this is penned by Robert Culp so it is equally of high quality in any season. Now, remember "The Warlord" which failed due to it being excessively serious. "Home to Judgment" is equally serious, but works. Why does it work? because this time we're doing character drama with characters we know and love. For such stories to work effectively, the viewer must "be one with the protagonist" or else you're wasting your time. And "Home" is definitely a classic.
Robert Culp, knowing that character-driven drama can be the most powerful of any type of drama, embraces this fact and, as usual, knits a tightly-written story filled with a very tense situation and very realistic people. Even the faceless villains, who only say two-dimensional lines over a radio such as "Primary targets in the barn, secondary targets in the house..." still end up being extremely vicious due to the brilliant use of Culp's style of writing.
We get to know more about Kelly's background and family (yippee!), and in a very interesting way as well. Also, Scott's loyalty to Kelly is quite obvious here. As always, the music fits the tone of the story - which adds even more to the tension.
What the guys do to protect Kelly's aunt's and uncle's house is quite ingenious, and I must admit that when the 'mailman' comes to the door, I didn't need Kelly's patronizing reassurance that the bad guys are now on their way... the scene felt natural, I just didn't need it (having no social life, I've seen so many TV shows and movies that I can pinpoint most of this stuff a mile away) and when the bad guys do arrive for the climactic battle, it's bone chilling (in my opinion) as to what happens. Very dark and gritty and I love it to pieces.
And the icing on the cake? That award goes to the music. The organ music is extremely haunting and chilling and is very appropriately placed.
I do have one problem: The end of act 4 sadly features Scotty shot and falling on the floor unconscious or dead after the others realize that all the bad guys have been killed. The epilogue features Scotty walking around as if nothing ever happened. Scotty's near-demise was daring and gripping, but the resolution was - I'm sorry - pathetic. Therefore I am compelled to take away half a point.
The acting and production couldn't be any better. It's a classic by any means or measures. I will still complain this deserves to be the season/series finale, instead of the dreaded "Pinwheel", because of Scotty's near-death experience.
Rating: 9.5/10
|